"He might be telling the truth."

"Well... we could drag him back at the end of a rope..."

"I'm not cool with that. I'll go in and check and if he kills me I expect to be avenged."

Barring any last minute attacks they'll lead Tyler back to the clearing with the bunker and the paint splattered 'kills' beginning what looks like a barbecue. Clarkson is missing his eyebrows, likely from starting the grill.